I am a long time fan of the Salad Fingers series
But Firth is just not the greatest animator.
Story aside a stand alone animation can be poor or great.
Take any modern cartoon (Yugioh, Atomic Betty, dinosaur bob or whatever the hell it's called) and you'll see that the graphics have become so factory fresh that they're dull in their own right.
I agree that these cartoons are dull and styleless but there still exists today very awesome cartoons with great animation.
(as I hardly watch Television anymore I cant name many)
Star Wars the clone wars is a good example the style they use in that series is breathtaking
though it is 3D that does not take away from the work put into it.
Compare these with older cartoons such as Ed, Edd and Eddy, Ren and Stimpy, cow and chicken, scooby doo and Tom and jerry. And you'll find a much more quirky an original set of styles and ideas within the gritty and haphazard animation.
In most of these cartoons the "gritty and haphazard" look was a style choice and the animation was really good.
I'm not saying that this is always the case, films such a Wall-e and Ice age, and animation such as, uh...Brackenwood! -Have both the high quality effects and innovative storylines and concepts. So I guess that all animation is good so long as you put more heart than money into it, just like any sort of artwork
Most Pixar films are good in both story and animation.
If you judge an Animated Movie you need to divide it into each, for lack of a better word, section just like any other kind of movie.
For an Animated Movie I personally look for
Story - as it is a key part of any movie it is literally the base of everything else in the movie
Animation - if this is lacking the story can make up for it but this can not make up for the story
Score - a less integral part of a movie but still very important this can set moods display emotion even define a character
Voice Acting - last but just as important as a score voice acting (if used) plays a key role in an animation I'm sure we've all seen a youtube video out of sync personally I can not finish it
it is far too distracting the same goes for bad voice acting if the actor doesn't sound like he is in pain when the character is hurt it is distracting and really hurts you involvement with said movie
[/rant]